Thursday, August 7, 2008

Coming Soon!

Here is a run down of what we can expect from the Black Library in the foreseeable future. For each I am rating (Must Have Now!, Looking Forward to It, Yawn) - each self expanatory. All dates are UK dates with US one month later.


Blood Angels : Red Fury byJames Swallow Sep 08 - Looking Forward to It. The third Blood Angels book. I heard an excellent interview on 40kRadio with Swallow about the book. He described it as a family reunion gone horribly wrong. It is supposed to include many of the Blood Angel successor chapters.

Only in Death (Softback) by Dan Abnett Oct 08 - Read it. Fair to middelin Gaunt's Ghost Book.

Titanicus byDan Abnett Oct 08 - Must Have Now! Giant sized Sabbat Worlds Crusade book plus a Titan legion! Also there are ties between this book and the next Horus Heresy book (Mechanicum)

Ciaphas Cain : Cains Last Stand by Sandy Mitchell Nov 08 - Must Have Now! I think Mitchell is one of the best authors in the Black Library. I have loved nearly every Ciaphas Cain book. I hope that this is not the last.

Horus Heresy : Mechanicum byGraham McNeill Dec 08 - Must Have Now! McNeill has written the best of the Horus Heresy. I can't wait (although his Mechanicum short story in the Collected Visions book was middelin).

Dark Disciple byAnthony Reynolds Dec 08 - Looking Forward To It. The second Word Bearer book. The first was a nice departure. Stars the worst of worse and true 40k bad guys- the Word Bearers.

Ice Guard by Steve Lyons Jan 09 - Yawn. Most of the IG books have been poor in my mind. There are positives for Fifteen Hours. But the other books have been poor. See the Catachan book (Death World) where the lone wolf hero is Sly Marbo (which funny enough is the same letters for Rambo and Sly for Stallone) and the Tallarn Book (Desert Raiders) which read like an agonizingly long short story. Rebel Winter was "just ok." Lyons has a tall order to have the Valahallans measure up to the Valhallans in Sandy Mitchell's books.

Innocence Proves Nothing bySandy Mitchell Feb 09 - Looking Forward To It. Sequel to Scourge the Heretic. I really like Mitchell's prose. I though Scourge the Heretic was mostly a succesful book. I look forward to this one.

Gunheads bySteve Parker Mar 09 - Yawn. "an armoured company is sent to recover a long-lost battle tank from a planet overrrun with orks." I feel like I have read this book before...twice.

Dawn of War : Dawn of War II by Chris Roberson Mar 09 - Yawn. I am struggling to get through the Dawn of War Omnibus. I don't think a novelization of a story built for a game will work a second time (it sure didn't the first).

Souldrinkers : Hellforged by Ben Counter Apr 09 - Looking Forward To It. I have enjoyed the adventures of Sarpedon and company. I want to see where Counter is going with it.

Horus Heresy : Tales of Heresy Nick Kyme, Lindsey Priestley Apr 09 - Looking Forward To It. I am not the biggest short story fan. However short stories on the Heresy should be good.

The Grey Knights Omnibus by Ben Counter May 09 - Read It. Mostly enjoyed it.

Gaunts Ghosts : Blood Pact by Dan Abnett May 09 - MUST HAVE NOW! Added the all caps. Of all the books on the list, this is the one I want. I can't wait.

What is not on the official list? Abnett said in a 40kRadio exclusive that he and Graham McNeill are working on companion Heresy novels concerning the sacking of Prospero. Abnett also said that he is doing a third trilogy on Inquisitors. He dubbed it "Eisenhorn versus Ravenor." I dub it (to be) the most anticipated book from Black Library since Horus Rising. Also Mike Lee is doing a Heresy novel on the Dark Angels.

Stay tuned...

Saturday, August 2, 2008

Big Update - More to Come

I have updated nearly all of the Black Library books I have read this year (which is nearly all of the 40k books released). I still have reviews of Relentless, Ravenor Rogue and Brothers of the Snake to do. I am currently reading the re-release of Angels of Darkness.

My reviews are pretty short. This is mostly because when I read online reviews I usually skim them over to get "an idea" of the reviewers perspective - hence the few musings. If there are particular questions please post a comment and I will respond.

Enjoy.

Storm of Iron by Graham McNeill


Vital Stats:
Page Count: 413
Era: 40k (no specified year)
Perspective: Iron Warriors
Major Characters: [Inquisitor-text]Honsou (Iron Warrior), Forrix (Iron Warrior), Vaubun (Imperial Guard), Kroeger (Iron Warrior), Guardsman Hawke (IG), Magos Naicin (Adeptus Mechanicus), Leonid (Imperial Guard), The Warsmith, (Frankly I could go on and on).
Special Guest Stars: [Inquisitor-text]Alaric Eshara
Location: Hydra Cordatus


One Sentence Review: Definitive novel for the phrase "in the grim dark future there is only war."

A Few Musings: This is easily the best 40k book I have read this year. This one has it all (literally). If McNeill threw in a rogue inquisitor, he would be batting 1.000. The pacing in this book is nonstop once it gets going (which it does quickly). The twists and turns are surprising and welcome. The battles are well conceived and beautifully described. This was one I could not put down and had me guessing until the last page.

The book feels like a war epic from the 1950s and early 1960s. There is a David Lean-esque majesty to some of the battles and it feels like there is a huge cast of characters...because there is a huge cast of characters. There are a number of set pieces in this book and each feels special.[Inquisitor-text] I particularly liked anything involving a titan and especially one sequence involving a missile. You will know what I mean when you see them.

I am very happy Black Library re-released the book. I had always looked for a copy, but did not get one until this year. I am very glad I did. [Inquisitor-text]I really want to see more of Honsou or books with action of this scale. This book should be the manual for how big battles are described for the Horus Heresy books (which have too few such battles so far).

I generally don't re-read books. However this one is marked to do so in the future.


Bolters (Out of Five): Five

Ultramarines - The Killing Ground by Graham McNeill


Vital Stats:
Page Count: 320
Era: 40k (no specified year)
Perspective: Ultramarines
Major Characters: Uriel Ventris, Pasanius Lysane
Special Guest Stars: [Inquisitor-text]Leodegarius

One Sentence Review: A personal story and conclusion to the story started in Dead Sky, Black Sun.

A Few Musings: The Ultramarines novels started incredibly strong. They are almost as good as what is my mind the best Space Marine story – Space Wolf by William King. Graham McNeill took a departure with Dead Sky, Black Sun with a more personal story involving Uriel and Pasanius. It wasn’t a departure I liked ([Inquisitor-text]see Chaos Choo-Choo). This story seems to atone for the past as it is a bridge to what I am hopeful are great things with Uriel (leading Ultramarines into battle).

I like the cover artwork. Although I wonder if the artist realized he was painting [Inquisitor-text]the sidekick of the story. The story itself is well laid out and comes to a decent conclusion. There was no real mystery to this book, although it tries to play one out. [Inquisitor-text]The Killing Ground wasn’t a big surprise and that was disappointing. How the Unfleshed were fleshed out (insert groan here) was quite good. Also when Leodegarius shows up the book got a lot better. Frankly I would like to see a book just about him (although another author has that topic cornered).

Surprisingly, the "personal" story of Ben Counter's Grey Knight Justicar Alaric was better than this book. I say surprising because I generally enjoy McNeill's books more than any other Black Library author.

I wasn’t really happy with a 320 page hardback. This is partially because I rip through McNeill’s books I must admit. Overall it is a good read, but I would wait for paperback.

Bolters (Out of Five): Two.

Wolf's Honor by Lee Lightner


Vital Stats:
Page Count: 414
Era: 40k (no specified year)
Perspective: Space Wolves
Major Characters: [Inquisitor-text]Ragnar Blackmane, Madox, (The Mighty) Haegr, Gabriella, Torin, Wolf Priest Sigurd
Special Guest Stars: [Inquisitor-text]Bulveye, Berek Thunderfist

One Sentence Review: Strong conclusion to the Wolfblade Trilogy

A Few Musings: Despite the monumental task of filling in for William King, the two anonymous writers who go by Lee Lightner have done a very good job of capturing the flavor of the colorful characters King invented. The story bring full circle Ragnar Blackmane and describes[Inquisitor-text] how he became a Wolf Guard without being a Grey Hunter. I liked how King used an older and wiser Ragnar reflecting back on his life to tell his story. I think Lightner raised the bar with[Inquisitor-text] a great reveal at the end that left me wanting more. The 40k universe to me would not be the same without [Inquisitor-text]Ragnar and (The Mighty) Haegr (else I would receive a thrashing). There is a very good sequence where Ragnar meets Bulveye. Although this site is "spoiler lite", I won't give anything else away. Also the ending and end sequences were well executed.

Despite the flavor text on the cover stating "The gripping conclusion to the saga of Ragnar Blackmane", [Inquisitor-text]I am hopeful that Lightner will write a book about Bulveye (and the group he is with) and Ragnar in the very near future.

Bolters (Out of Five): Three

Hammer of Daemons by Ben Counter




Vital Stats:
Page Count:
415
Era: 40k (no specified year - presume M41.999 - 13th Black Crusade)
Perspective: Grey Knights (Justicar Alaric)
Major Characters: [Inquisitor-text]Justicar Alaric, Duke Venalitor (Khorne), Lord Ebondrake (Khorne), Raezazel the Cunning (Tzeentch)
Special Guest Stars: [Inquisitor-text]Disembodied Voice - presumably Tzeentch
Locations: [Inquisitor-text]Sarthis Majoris, Drakaasi



One Sentence Review: 40k meets Sparatacus.
A Few Musings: I have been a fan of this series by Ben Counter. I don't think it is the best Space Marine series, but it the best of the different Chamber Militant books (Deathwatch series and Faith and Fire being the others). The book opens [Inquisitor-text]with a large engagement and then continues with Justicar Alaric (the star of the series) becoming a gladiator on a Khorne world. Some of the characters are unique for 40k fiction ([Inquisitor-text]Lord Ebondrake - who is literally an ebon drake). The action is well described. When you discover [Inquisitor-text]what the Hammer of Daemons is (beyond the catchecism) it is a good reveal. My biggest criticism of Black Library books is that I usually feel that the author runs out of pagecount and quickly deus ex machinas the ending. This ending was very smooth and well conceived.



A positive to the book is that unlike the last two Grey Knights novels [Inquisitor-text]this one is only about Alaric. The Epilogue suggests an interesting turn for the series and where it is suggested that Counter will go is something I am hoping he skips as there are already enough series covering that topic as is. Personally I would like to see more of the Grey Knights fighting Chaos in all of its forms.



Bolters (Out of Five): Three

Thursday, July 31, 2008

Horus Heresy: Battle for the Abyss by Ben Counter


Vital Stats:
Page Count: 416
Era: Heresy (30,000)
Perspective: Ultramarines
Major Characters: [Inquisitor-text]Brother-Captain Cestus (Ultramarines), Admiral Zadkiel (Word Bearers), Wolf Guard Brynngar (Space Wolves), Mhotep (Thousand Sons), Skraal (World Eater),
Special Guest Stars: [Inquisitor-text]Kor Phareon (Word Bearers), Kelbor-Hal (Fabricator General of the Mechanicum)
Locations: [Inquisitor-text]Sol System, The Warp, Ultramar System

One Sentence Review: 30k meets the Hunt for Red October sans Primarchs.

A Few Musings: This is the first Horus Hersey book[Inquisitor-text] without a primarch in it. I want to start the review there because it is the books greatest strength and biggest weakness. The basic plot is[Inquisitor-text] that the Fabricator General of Mars has devised the largest warship ever created in secret. Granted to the Word Bearers, the ship The Furious Abyss leaves space dock around Jupiter to destroy the Ultramarines Legion. After the ship leaves dock it performs a shake down by annhilating an Ultramarines vessel. Brother-Captain Cestus, the protagonist, is waiting to return home with an honor guard retinue of Ultramarines on a nearby space station. When the aforementioned Ultramarine vessel does not arrive, Cestus deduces that something is afoot. This is confirmed to him in a vision and the death scream of the astropaths aboard the Ultramarine ship. Assembling other space marines on the station (World Eaters, Space Wolves and a lone and mysterious Thousand Son), Cestus pursues The Furious Abyss across the galaxy.

If this book had been set in the 40k era, it would have been better in my opinion. Unlike the recent Horus Heresy novels with dramatic reveals and very interesting characters, this novel felt a step backward for the series. It isn't a bad book, but just not up to the calibur of the others in the series. Counter is generally better with the "big concept" than the execution. His action is stronger than his characters. Also many of his characters fall into stereotypes with which we are very familiar.

Bolters (Out of Five): Two

About This Website/Spoiler Policy

The purpose of this blog is to review Black Library books in the Warhammer 40k setting. Since November 2005 I have read nearly every Black Library novel (and short story) published in the 40k universe. Since Black Library has published many books (good and bad), I have done a lot of reading. The books are compelling and does credit to the incredible setting of Warhammer 40k. This blog is to chronicle my thoughts and my reviews of Warhammer 40k fiction.

My reviews are organized by giving a short synopis. I follow this with a one sentence review. This is kind of a "pitch" to you the reader as to why you would read the book. This is followed by some "musings" of mine of what I liked and disliked about the book. The final "grade" is a number of bolters. This is a general outline of how I felt about the book. Here are some examples,

Five Bolters - Exceptional 40k novel, would be considered great in any genre - Storm of Iron, Sabbat Martyr

Four Bolters - Very good 40k novel, any fan of 40k would enjoy - Ravenor, Horus Rising

Three Bolters - Good 40k novel, occassional Black Library readers should pick it up - The Traitor's Hand, Fifteen Hours

Two Bolters - Average to Below Average 40k novel, die hard Black Library fans will want to read - Rebel Winter, Dead Sky, Black Sun

One Bolter - Poor 40k book, everyone should avoid - Inquisition War, Lord of Night

Disclaimer

This web site is completely unofficial and in no way endorsed by Games Workshop Limited. Adeptus Astartes, Battlefleet Gothic, Black Flame, Black Library, the Black Library logo, BL Publishing, Blood Angels, Bloodquest, Blood Bowl, the Blood Bowl logo, The Blood Bowl Spike Device, Cadian, Catachan, the Chaos device, Cityfight, the Chaos logo, Citadel, Citadel Device, City of the Damned, Codex, Daemonhunters, Dark Angels, Dark Eldar, Dark Future, the Double-Headed/Imperial Eagle device, 'Eavy Metal, Eldar, Eldar symbol devices, Epic, Eye of Terror, Fanatic, the Fanatic logo, the Fanatic II logo, Fire Warrior, Forge World, Games Workshop, Games Workshop logo, Genestealer, Golden Demon, Gorkamorka, Great Unclean One, the Hammer of Sigmar logo, Horned Rat logo, Inferno, Inquisitor, the Inquisitor logo, the Inquisitor device, Inquisitor:Conspiracies, Keeper of Secrets, Khemri, Khorne, Kroot, Lord of Change, Marauder, Mordheim, the Mordheim logo, Necromunda, Necromunda stencil logo, Necromunda Plate logo, Necron, Nurgle, Ork, Ork skull devices, Sisters of Battle, Skaven, the Skaven symbol devices, Slaanesh, Space Hulk, Space Marine, Space Marine chapters, Space Marine chapter logos, Talisman, Tau, the Tau caste designations, Tomb Kings, Trio of Warriors, Twin Tailed Comet Logo, Tyranid, Tyrannid, Tzeentch, Ultramarines, Warhammer, Warhammer Historical, Warhammer Online, Warhammer 40k Device, Warhammer World logo, Warmaster, White Dwarf, the White Dwarf logo, and all associated marks, names, races, race insignia, characters, vehicles, locations, units, illustrations and images from the Blood Bowl game, the Warhammer world, the Talisaman world, and the Warhammer 40,000 universe are either ®, TM and/or © Copyright Games Workshop Ltd 2000-2007, variably registered in the UK and other countries around the world. Used without permission. No challenge to their status intended. All Rights Reserved to their respective owners.